Do you think organizations should be required to share salary ranges in their job postings?

  • George YangGeorge Yang
    Community Manager
      May 16, 2024 at 12:21
    • Caitlin Henderson, PCPCaitlin Henderson, PCP
      Advocates Council

        Yes absolutely! Often organizations want employees to desire work for other reasons other than pay, such as career advancement and a positive work environment. While These are great reasons to choose a company and should be factors when making your choice, at the end of the day everyone work’s to pay their bills and enjoy life outside of work. Salary is the top contributor to a positive work life balance and being able to rest so you can get back to enjoying work.

        May 17, 2024 at 10:30
      • Denise BurnettDenise Burnett
        Member since Apr 2022

          Yes they absolutely should. Candidates are looking for a number of things from a new position but salary is definitely at the top of the list. It is a need and not just a nice to have like some other elements of the job. I have been in the position before where I applied to a job, it was a great fit, they were interested in my skill set and offered me the job, and I would have taken it, but the offered salary was way too low for me to even consider it. They didn’t have the salary in the posting and wouldn’t discuss the salary earlier on in the process. It ended up being a waste of time for them and for me because if I had known the salary sooner, I wouldn’t even have applied. It doesn’t do anyone any favours to keep it secret and just wastes valuable time in finding the right candidate.

          May 22, 2024 at 09:56
        • Cindy LewisCindy Lewis
          Member since Sep 2022

            Yes I agree that salary ranges should be posted. It not only wastes the candidates time but also wastes the company’s managers time when reaching out to applicants and interviewing candidates to then find out that they turn down the job due to the wage offered at or after the interview. The only company’s that oppose this idea are those companys who have an unfair wage progression system in place for their current employees.

            May 23, 2024 at 13:14
            • Matthew MacPherson, PLPMatthew MacPherson, PLP
              Member since Jun 2022

                Having come through a job transition just recently, I can say while looking, I avoided a number without them. The few I did apply for were a waste of time based on my expectation. I never thought of the other side though. That would be so tedious to sit through so many interviews or conversations by email just to not hire someone due to something as simple as a difference in expectation of wage.

                June 19, 2024 at 11:52
            • Heather ShawHeather Shaw
              Member since May 2022

                Yes, I do. Full stop.

                May 23, 2024 at 15:12
              • Stacey Wood PCPStacey Wood PCP
                Advocates Council

                  Of course salary ranges should be included in job postings. A job is a business transaction, with the exchange of compensation for services. There’s always (or sometimes?) a bigger picture including company culture, but end of the day, money is required to live your life–including this data in job postings allows potential employees to make an informed decision on whether to apply or not, & can save so much time for all parties involved.

                  May 28, 2024 at 12:58
                • Kathryn HillKathryn Hill
                  Advocates Council

                    Posting salary ranges can be helpful to those applying for a position but be sure to talk about the Total Compensation picture as well. Some companies have profit sharing, time in lieu programs, healthcare spending programs and mentor programs. A job is just not “money” only. Both the employee and employer need to find a good fit for each other.

                    May 29, 2024 at 18:05
                  • Sarah HamlinSarah Hamlin
                    Member since Jul 2022

                      Absolutely! I was very glad to hear that, in Ontario, job postings must now include compensation range information per the Employment Standards Act Part III.3:
                      https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/00e41#BK13

                      July 15, 2024 at 11:38
                    • Elena NiculaeElena Niculae
                      Member since Jul 2024

                        I don’t believe in a “should” approach, but in doing what’s best to achieve the desired outcome. As a strong advocate for transparency and equitable pay, I’ve seen firsthand how pay transparency contributes to organizational success. However, many organizations lack the internal capacity to establish an equitable pay system.

                        When legal regulations mandate salary ranges in job postings, companies are compelled to examine their pay practices and consider equity and market alignment. Some embrace this opportunity to become better employers, while others seek loopholes to maintain their status quo.

                        Publicly shared salary ranges alone won’t solve the problem. A wide range, like $70,000 to $130,000, can attract candidates at various experience levels. A senior candidate expecting $120,000 to $130,000 might be disappointed to learn the target salary is $70,000. This doesn’t save time, reduce the gender pay gap, or align compensation with market rates.

                        Ultimately, organizations have a choice to adopt best pay practices or strive towards them, or do nothing at all. Education and case studies emphasizing the benefits of pay transparency can be more effective than mandated salary ranges in job postings. People, not regulations, drive change. A shift in perspective can lead to better outcomes.

                        July 23, 2024 at 18:00
                      • Bianca Mueller, CPBBianca Mueller, CPB
                        Advocates Council

                          Yes! This is so important for many reasons but more importantly to close the gender pay gap. Women and gender-diverse people continue to earn on avg 17% less than men. This also impacts Indigenous, disabled, racialized and LGBTQ+ people.

                          Thankfully job postings for BC have this as mandatory for all provincially regulated employers under the Pay Transparency Act. Other provinces should follow suit!

                          August 12, 2024 at 12:24